Showing posts with label Prestige. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Prestige. Show all posts

Interstellar sucks. Sure, but why?

The experience of watching a Nolan movie can be summarized by this picture below.



She is a beautiful young and fashionable girl, right?
Now slowly shift your gaze down to the black line in the neck.

Focus.
Are you watching closely?

Do you see now a different image now?
Aha!


That Aha! moment is the core of a Nolan movie. Everything in a Nolan's movie is directed towards amplifying that Aha! moment. He makes the Aha! moment significantly rewarding by following some great techniques.

1. Keeps the surface level idea (the young girl in the above image) simple for people to grasp.
2. keeps the underlying idea well hidden (but litters the movie with clues, minor Ahas! when we watch the movie again)
3. Reveals the underlying idea (old woman in the above image) in a sudden climax
4. Connects the two ideas in a profound philosophical manner
(Young girl and old woman in the same image above is a philosophical goldmine.)

In his movie Prestige, at surface level, two magicians try to outdo each other with disastrous results. In the climax, it is revealed that the greatest magic is ... the magician. A powerful Aha! moment, because the movie lingers as you think about the what artists pay for perfection, et al..

But what is the surface level idea in Interstellar? A father leaves behind his family in dying earth and goes to space to find alternatives. Okay, this is a trite idea. But we go because, it is Christopher Nolan movie! He is going to take surface level scientific ideas like slowing of time and gravity that doesn't allow even light to escape, turn them on their head and reveal something profound to us, right?

No! He is going to tell that love (and gravity) travels across dimension and time and a father will keep his promise to his daughter, even from beyond black hole. Pleeeeasse...

In Nolan movies, we have come to expect a reveal in the end. A reveal that is mind boggling. But in interstellar, there was no reveal in the end. There is just relief.
Plain relief.